top of page
Search

Who Are You? Why Identity Doesn't Have to Divide Us This Thanksgiving

1 day ago
7 min read

BLOG POST | IDENTITY, FAMILY & THANKSGIVING


multigenerational family talking at dinner table

Our identity is shaped by our experiences, memories, relationships, and values. But what happens when the people closest to us see us differently than we see ourselves?

Thanksgiving is approaching, and with it comes the opportunity to gather with family, share memories, and celebrate our connections. Yet, for many families, this time of year also brings tension. Conversations turn into arguments, old resentments resurface, and what was meant to be a celebration of togetherness becomes a reminder of how different we are.

Why does this happen? I believe part of the answer lies in something we rarely stop to question: our identity and the expectations we attach to it.


What makes you who you are?

Think about how you would answer the question, "Who are you?"

You might start by saying you're a mother, a father, a son, a daughter, a professional, or a student. You might mention your nationality, religion, or cultural background. Perhaps you would describe yourself as creative, hardworking, generous, or someone who always puts family first.

But are any of these descriptions the whole of who you are?

Our sense of self develops through our memories, experiences, relationships, and the values we form along the way. Everything we have lived, the people we have encountered, and the choices we have made contribute to the story we tell ourselves about who we are.

Here's something important to remember: that story is not finished.

Our identity is not something fixed that we receive at birth and carry unchanged throughout our lives. As we gain new experiences, build relationships, and question old beliefs, our understanding of ourselves can change.

The person you were at fifteen is probably quite different from the person you are today. And the person you will become ten years from now may see the world differently, too.

That doesn't mean you have lost yourself. It means you have continued living, learning, and growing.


We can belong to the same family and have different stories

We are all part of different groups: families, communities, countries, religions, and cultures. These groups influence how we see ourselves, but belonging to the same group doesn't mean experiencing it in the same way.

Think about two siblings growing up in the same household. They have the same parents, perhaps attend the same schools, and share many family traditions. Yet, when they become adults and talk about their childhood, they may describe two completely different experiences.

One might remember a loving, supportive home, while the other remembers feeling unheard or constantly compared to their sibling.

Which one is right?

Both may be describing their genuine experiences. They lived in the same home, but they did not experience every interaction in the same way.

The same happens within countries, communities, and cultures. We may share an origin without sharing the same interpretation of its history, values, or traditions.

Sharing a history does not require sharing the same perspective.

This is where identity can become a source of conflict, particularly within families.


When our identity becomes something we need others to confirm

Imagine a parent who has spent years believing they have been a wonderful mother or father. They have worked hard, made sacrifices, and provided opportunities for their children. They see themselves as someone who has done everything possible to give their children a good life.

Then, during Thanksgiving dinner, their adult son says, "I never felt you listened to me when I was growing up."

Suddenly, what could have been a joyful dinner becomes an argument.

The parent responds, "How can you say that after everything I've done for you?"

Why such a strong reaction?

Because the son's experience seems to contradict the parent's identity. The parent sees themselves as loving and supportive, and now someone they love is describing a different reality.

But here's the question: Does someone else's experience invalidate your identity?

Not necessarily.

You can have been a loving parent who made enormous sacrifices and still have moments when your child felt unheard. Both experiences can exist without canceling each other out.

The difficulty begins when we feel that we must defend our entire identity rather than listen to what someone is telling us.

And this doesn't only happen between parents and children. It happens between siblings, partners, friends, and across generations.


You are more than the labels you carry

Throughout my life, I have lived in different countries and belonged to different cultures. I have identified as a mother, daughter, sister, friend, artist, and coach. Each of these roles and experiences has contributed to who I am today.

But none of them defines me completely.

My connection to a country doesn't mean I agree with every decision made by its government. My identity as a mother doesn't mean I have always made the right decisions. And my belief that I am someone who listens doesn't mean there haven't been times when I failed to listen.

If someone tells me, "You're not listening," I have a choice.

I can take it as an attack on who I believe I am and immediately defend myself. Or I can become curious and ask, "What am I missing? What is this person trying to tell me?"

The second response doesn't require me to abandon my identity. It simply allows me to learn something about myself.

This is particularly important when dealing with teenagers and young adults, who are still exploring who they are and how they want to live their lives.

A young man might grow up in a family where academic achievement is considered the greatest measure of success, yet discover that his interests and talents lead him in a completely different direction. He may love his family and appreciate his upbringing while choosing values and goals that differ from those of his parents.

His choices don't necessarily mean he is rejecting his family. He may simply be discovering his own identity.

And for parents, allowing that discovery can be difficult, especially when their own identity is closely connected to their children's achievements and decisions.


This Thanksgiving, try curiosity instead of defending yourself

What would happen if, instead of trying to convince everyone at the table that our perspective is the correct one, we became curious about how others see the world?

What if, when someone shares a memory that differs from ours, we ask them to tell us more rather than immediately correcting them?

And what if we stopped expecting our children to reflect our values, opinions, and choices as proof that we have been good parents?

We don't need to agree with every perspective. We don't even need to change our beliefs. But we can acknowledge that another person's experiences are real to them, even when they differ from our own.

There is also an important distinction between belonging and agreeing.

You can belong to a family without sharing all its beliefs. You can honor your origins without wanting to repeat every tradition. You can love your parents while recognizing that some of their choices hurt you.

Our origins are part of our story, whether we embrace every aspect of them or not. And we can decide what parts of that story we want to carry forward.

However, harmony doesn't mean pretending that painful experiences never happened. Sometimes maintaining a healthy relationship requires setting boundaries or accepting that certain conversations need more time and care.

But when there is room for mutual respect, differences don't have to become divisions.


You don't have to prove who you are

Perhaps one of the most freeing things we can learn is that we don't need everyone around us to confirm our identity.

You don't need your children to tell you that you were a perfect parent to recognize the love and effort you put into raising them. You don't need your parents to approve of every decision you make to know that your life has value. And you don't need to defend every aspect of your culture, profession, or beliefs to maintain a connection with them.

Your identity belongs to you. It is influenced by your past, but identity is not a prison by.

You can change your mind, discover new interests, recognize mistakes and choose to do things differently. You can continue becoming the person you want to be.

And you can allow others to do the same.

As Thanksgiving approaches, I invite you to think about one question:

Are you going to the family gathering hoping that everyone will recognize you as the person you believe you are, or are you going with the curiosity to discover who the people around you have become?

That small change in perspective might make the difference between an uncomfortable family gathering and a meaningful opportunity to reconnect.

After all, the purpose of gathering around a table is to recognize that, despite our differences, there is still be something valuable connecting us.


When identity gets in the way of connection

As a certified life coach and artist, I work with teenagers and young adults to help them understand themselves, build confidence, and find their own direction. Through coaching conversations and creative exercises, I encourage them to explore their values, recognize the beliefs that may be limiting them, and develop the confidence to make choices that reflect who they want to become.

I also understand how challenging it can be for parents to support that process, particularly when their children's choices or experiences differ from their own expectations.

If you're struggling to understand the young person your child is becoming, or if you're a young adult feeling pressured to live according to someone else's definition of who you should be, I invite you to reach out.

Sometimes, learning to see ourselves and one another from a different perspective is the beginning of a better relationship.


Daniela DohnertCertified Life Coach | Visual Artist

Helping teens and young adults build confidence, understand themselves, and find their own path.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page